Top Auto Insurance Provider That Offers Auto Insurance With No Deposit in 2025 (Save With These 10 Companies!)

Embark on a journey through the top auto insurance providers that offer auto insurance with no deposit like Progressive, USAA, and State Farm. Progressive emerges as a beacon of affordability, convenience, and comprehensive coverage. 

Car insurance is a necessary expense that most drivers would love to minimize. Depending on your age, gender, and driving history, your quoted rates for auto insurance could be relatively high. You may have seen very cheap car insurance with no deposit advertised, but buyer beware.

Our Top 10 Best Companies: Top Auto Insurance Provider that Offers Auto Insurance with No Deposit

Not only is no-deposit car insurance a misnomer, but this payment structure can end up costing you hundreds of dollars more long term. If you are looking to find the top auto insurance discounts, it is essential to explore your options.

#1 – Progressive: Pioneering Affordability and Convenience

Pros

• Competitive rates: Progressive is known for offering competitive rates for auto insurance, making it an attractive option for budget-conscious customers.

• Online convenience: Progressive stands out for its user-friendly online platform, providing customers with the convenience of managing their policies, filing claims, and accessing information online.

• Diverse discounts: Progressive offers a range of discounts, including multi-policy and low-mileage discounts, providing policyholders with opportunities to further reduce their insurance costs.

Cons

• Limited coverage information: The content does not provide specific details about the average monthly rate for good drivers or additional coverage options, making it challenging to assess the complete scope of Progressive’s offerings.

• Not specified complaint level: While mentioned as “low,” the content does not provide specific information about the complaint level for Progressive, leaving potential customers without detailed insights into customer satisfaction.

Read more: Progressive Car Insurance Review

#2 – USAA: Exemplary Savings and Support for Military Members

Pros

• Low average monthly rate: USAA offers a notably low average monthly rate for good drivers, making it an appealing choice for those seeking affordable auto insurance.

• Military savings: USAA is specifically recognized for catering to military members and their families, providing unique benefits and discounts tailored to their needs.

• High A.M. best rating: With an A+ A.M. Best rating, USAA demonstrates financial stability and reliability, assuring customers of the company’s ability to fulfill its financial obligations.

Cons

• Limited availability: USAA membership is limited to military members, veterans, and their families, restricting access to a specific demographic and excluding the general public.

• Not specified complaint level: While mentioned as “low,” the content does not provide specific information about the complaint level for USAA, leaving potential customers without detailed insights into customer satisfaction.

Read more: USAA Car Insurance Review

#3 – State Farm: Unrivaled Variety and Abundance of Discounts

Pros

• Many discounts: State Farm is praised for offering numerous discounts, including multi-policy and low-mileage discounts, giving policyholders various opportunities to save on their insurance premiums.

• Long-standing reputation: State Farm has a longstanding reputation in the insurance industry, providing a sense of stability and trust for customers seeking a reliable insurance provider.

• Maximum low-mileage discount: With a maximum low-mileage discount of up to 20%, State Farm encourages and rewards policyholders for driving fewer miles, potentially reducing their insurance costs.

Cons

• Not provided average monthly rate: The content does not provide information about the average monthly rate for good drivers with State Farm, making it challenging to compare the cost-effectiveness of their policies.

• Not specified A.M. best rating: The content does not specify State Farm’s A.M. Best rating, an important factor in assessing the financial strength and stability of an insurance company. Customers may lack crucial information for decision-making.

Read more: State Farm Car Insurance Review

#4 – Allstate: Leading the Pack With Comprehensive Coverage and Incentives

Pros

• Maximum multi-policy discount: Allstate offers a significant multi-policy discount of up to 25%, providing policyholders with the opportunity to save on their premiums by bundling different insurance policies.

• Maximum low-mileage discount: With a maximum low-mileage discount of up to 30%, Allstate rewards customers for driving fewer miles, potentially leading to substantial savings on their auto insurance.

• Add-on coverages: Allstate is noted for providing a variety of add-on coverages, allowing customers to customize their policies to better suit their individual needs and preferences.

Cons

• Higher full coverage rates: The provided data indicates that Allstate’s full coverage rates are relatively higher compared to some other companies, potentially making it less competitive in terms of overall cost.

• Not specified complaint level: The content does not provide specific information about the complaint level for Allstate, leaving potential customers without detailed insights into customer satisfaction.

Read more: Allstate Car Insurance Review

#5 – Liberty Mutual: Tailoring Policies for Maximum Savings and Flexibility

Pros

• Maximum multi-policy discount: Liberty Mutual offers a substantial multi-policy discount of up to 25%, encouraging customers to bundle multiple insurance policies for added savings.

• Maximum low-mileage discount: With a maximum low-mileage discount of up to 30%, Liberty Mutual incentivizes policyholders to drive less, potentially reducing their overall insurance costs.

• Customizable policies: Liberty Mutual is recognized for providing customizable policies, allowing customers to tailor their coverage to better align with their specific needs and preferences.

Cons

• Higher full coverage rates: The provided data indicates that Liberty Mutual’s full coverage rates are relatively higher compared to some other companies, potentially making it less competitive in terms of overall cost.

• Not specified complaint level: The content does not provide specific information about the complaint level for Liberty Mutual, leaving potential customers without detailed insights into customer satisfaction.

Read more: Liberty Mutual Car Insurance Review

#6 – Nationwide: Personalized Discounts and Localized Service Excellence

Pros

• Maximum multi-policy discount: Nationwide offers a substantial multi-policy discount of up to 20%, providing customers with the opportunity to save on their premiums by bundling different insurance policies.

• Maximum usage discount: Nationwide stands out with a usage discount of up to 25%, rewarding policyholders for using their vehicles less frequently and driving fewer miles.

• Local agents: Nationwide is known for having local agents, offering a personalized touch to customer service and assistance.

Cons

• Not specified low-mileage discount: The content does not provide information about the low-mileage discount offered by Nationwide, making it challenging to assess the full spectrum of potential savings.

• Not specified complaint level: The content does not provide specific information about the complaint level for Nationwide, leaving potential customers without detailed insights into customer satisfaction.

#7 – Farmers: Balancing Localized Expertise With Substantial Savings

Pros

• Up to 20% multi-policy discount: Farmers offers a multi-policy discount of up to 20%, allowing customers to save on their premiums by bundling different insurance policies with the company.

• Up to 22% low-mileage discount: With a maximum low-mileage discount of up to 22%, Farmers incentivizes policyholders to drive less, potentially leading to lower overall insurance costs.

• Local agents: Farmers is known for having local agents, providing customers with a personalized and localized approach to insurance services and assistance.

Cons

• Not specified complaint level: The content does not provide specific information about the complaint level for Farmers, leaving potential customers without detailed insights into customer satisfaction.

• Limited information on discounts: While some discount percentages are mentioned, the content does not provide a comprehensive list of all discounts offered by Farmers, potentially limiting the visibility of available savings options.

Read more: Farmers Car Insurance Review

#8 – Esurance: Streamlined Savings and Diverse Policy Options

Pros

• Up to 25% multi-policy discount: Esurance offers a significant multi-policy discount of up to 25%, encouraging customers to bundle multiple insurance policies for added savings.

• Up to 30% low-mileage discount: With a maximum low-mileage discount of up to 30%, Esurance rewards policyholders for driving fewer miles, potentially resulting in substantial savings on their auto insurance.

• Policy options: Esurance is recognized for providing a variety of policy options, allowing customers to choose coverage that aligns with their specific needs and preferences.

Cons

• Not specified complaint level: The content does not provide specific information about the complaint level for Esurance, leaving potential customers without detailed insights into customer satisfaction.

• May require good driving record: The content does not specify the eligibility criteria for discounts, and Esurance may require policyholders to have a good driving record to qualify for the maximum discounts.

Read more: Esurance Auto Insurance Review

#9 – Travelers: Precision in Pricing and Forgiveness for Unexpected Events

Pros

• Up to 13% multi-policy discount: Travelers offers a multi-policy discount of up to 13%, providing customers with the opportunity to save on their premiums by bundling different insurance policies.

• Up to 17% accident forgiveness: With a maximum accident forgiveness discount of up to 17%, Travelers provides policyholders with a potential reduction in premiums even after an at-fault accident.

• Customizable coverage: Travelers is known for providing customizable coverage options, allowing customers to tailor their policies to better suit their individual needs.

Cons

• Not specified low-mileage discount: The content does not provide information about the low-mileage discount offered by Travelers, making it challenging to assess the full spectrum of potential savings.

• Not specified complaint level: The content does not provide specific information about the complaint level for Travelers, leaving potential customers without detailed insights into customer satisfaction.

Read more: Travelers Car Insurance Review

#10 – American Family: Nurturing Family Finances With Diverse Discounts

Pros

• Up to 20% multi-policy discount: American Family offers a multi-policy discount of up to 20%, allowing customers to save on their premiums by bundling different insurance policies with the company.

• Up to 20% student savings: With a maximum student savings discount of up to 20%, American Family provides potential cost savings for student drivers and their families.

• Policy options: American Family is recognized for providing a variety of policy options, allowing customers to choose coverage that aligns with their specific needs and preferences.

Cons

• Not specified complaint level: The content does not provide specific information about the complaint level for American Family, leaving potential customers without detailed insights into customer satisfaction.

• Limited information on discounts: While some discount percentages are mentioned, the content does not provide a comprehensive list of all discounts offered by American Family, potentially limiting the visibility of available savings options.

Read more: American Family Auto Insurance Review

Illustrating the Top 10 Car Insurance Companies That Offers No Deposit

A new wave of flexibility emerges as top companies offer coverage without demanding hefty upfront deposits. Progressive leads the charge with a modest $65 for minimum coverage and an affordable $150 for comprehensive protection. USAA follows closely, catering to the military community with an enticing $50 for basic coverage and a competitive $120 for full protection.

Average Monthly Auto Insurance Rates for Insurance Provider that Offers Auto Insurance with No Deposit

Other major players like State Farm, Allstate, Liberty Mutual, Nationwide, Farmers, Esurance, Travelers, and American Family join the movement, presenting rates that challenge the traditional norms of deposit-heavy policies. This shift provides drivers with a range of options to choose from, emphasizing affordability and accessibility in the evolving landscape of auto insurance.

However, as drivers explore this no-deposit frontier, it’s essential to consider factors beyond mere rates. The complete evaluation should encompass overall coverage, customer service, and potential hidden fees associated with these plans. In navigating this new paradigm, consumers must carefully compare offerings to find the most suitable and cost-effective option.

Which very cheap car insurance requires no deposit?

So you just got a new set of wheels, and you’re excited to go for a drive. Of course, you need insurance first, but you just spent your savings on a new car. When shopping for a car insurance policy, you may have discovered a few companies that advertise very cheap car insurance with no deposit. Is this type of car insurance policy really all it’s cracked up to be?

Many people struggle to come up with the funds to pay for a car insurance policy upfront. Some impatient drivers are tempted by instant auto insurance, no down payment required, dirt cheap policies. Are these buy now, pay later car insurance policies legit? Will you actually save money with no down payment car insurance when it comes to brass tacks?

The truth is no down payment car insurance doesn’t exist. This title is mostly a marketing strategy for car insurance policies that you can pay monthly instead of annually. It is impossible to start a car insurance policy without paying for the first month. No deposit car insurance policies require some amount of money upfront.

Car insurance policies advertised as no deposit are only allowed in select states. This limited availability can significantly limit your opportunity to take out a no-deposit car insurance policy, depending on your location.

Read more: Best Auto Insurance for a New Car

States That Allow No Deposit Car Insurance

• Arizona
• California
• Florida
• Georgia
• New York
• Oklahoma
• Washington

If your state isn’t listed, don’t fret. Actual no-deposit car insurance might be borderline fictitious and not widely available, but monthly payment options exist for most people.

Read more:

• Cheapest Florida Auto Insurance Providers
• Cheapest California Auto Insurance Providers
• Top Florida Auto Insurance Providers
• Best No Down Payment Auto Insurance

Leading auto insurance companies allow some drivers to pay their car insurance rates monthly instead of the whole year upfront. These policies still require a deposit which can be upwards of 20% of the annual rate. Some auto insurance companies allow you to pay a small deposit, sometimes as low as a $20 down payment.

For an example of the low deposit monthly rates for liability-only insurance for a 30-year-old male driver in New York City with a 2015 Ford Taurus and clean driving record, take a look at these top auto insurance companies:

• Progressive – $160
• Geico – $71
• State Farm – $58
• USAA – $35

If you can take out a car insurance policy with no deposit, you will likely spend more money on your rates. As previously mentioned, no deposit car insurance doesn’t genuinely exist.

Companies redistribute the initial deposit into the monthly payments for car insurance policies advertised as no deposit. Interest and fees are also rolled into the monthly rates, so you end up spending more with this payment structure when it’s all added up.

For example, suppose you get a quote for a car insurance policy across both payment structures. Basic math can help show you the difference in cost. Let’s say a hypothetical auto insurance company offers liability-only car insurance quoted at $1,000 annually. If you want to pay monthly, they require a 20% down deposit equaling $200.

Upon exploring your options further, you discover that they offer a no-deposit payment structure. You are quoted $95 a month for a no-deposit payment plan. In effect, this means the $200 deposit is included in the monthly payments along with interest and fees.

Comparing Costs for No Deposit Car Insurance

Cost	Paid In Full	Deposit	No Deposit
Upfront	$1,000	$200	$0
Monthly	$0	$67	$95
Total	$1,000	$1,004	$1,140

Over the course of your insured year, you will end up spending $140 more than if you had gone with paying the annual rate upfront or the $200 deposit.

Can you get the first month free for car insurance?

If you’re struggling with bills but you know you’ll have the funds soon, then you might be wondering why you can’t find car insurance with the first month free. There is a good reason why auto insurance companies do not offer the first month free.

Primarily, you are not insured unless you’ve actually invested money into your policy. If auto insurance companies offer the first month free, some drivers will undoubtedly take advantage of this. (For more information, read our “Are auto insurance companies allowed to charge a policy fee?“).

Sometimes drivers will purchase an auto insurance policy to prove compliance with the government or the lessor of their vehicle. Once they have the paperwork to prove they have insurance, they often stop paying their rates.

This type of behavior is a liability for the insurance company, so they have measures to protect against it. If the insured must cough up a sizable chunk of change to start the policy, they are less likely to abandon it. Even if they do default on their policy, the insurance company has already collected a portion of the rates.

Tips for Finding Dirt Cheap Car Insurance

Car insurance is an expensive but necessary part of life. You may feel disheartened to learn that very cheap car insurance with no deposit doesn’t truly exist. Don’t feel too discouraged, though, because there are other ways to save money on your car insurance rates.

Top auto insurance companies offer promotions like the following:

• Safe driver discounts. Safe driver discounts rely on black box technology, also known as telematics devices, to monitor your driving behavior. If you are able to prove to the auto insurance company that you are a safe driver, they discount your rates as a reward.
• Good student discounts. Good student discounts are a boon for new drivers. Younger drivers can save money on their car insurance rates by performing well in school. This promotion is a great incentive to buckle down and study. The long-term financial rewards can help keep rates low if you stay with the same auto insurance company.
• Bundle and save deals. Top car insurance companies offer promotions to save money if you bundle your car insurance with other insurance. Bundle options include, but are not limited to, home, renters, RV, and boat insurance.

As you can see, there are ways you can save money and get dirt cheap car insurance depending on your location and situation. The most critical money-saving tip for any insurance is thoroughly exploring your options. That’s why comparing car insurance quotes can save you hundreds of dollars.

Read more: Best Auto Insurance for New Drivers

Is buy now, pay later car insurance the right option for you?

You may have recently seen very cheap car insurance with no deposit advertised. Like many insurance shoppers, you may be wondering if it’s too good to be true. The hard truth is that instant car insurance with no deposit doesn’t exist. A monthly payment structure can be more accessible for individuals who cannot afford a larger upfront payment. Unfortunately, however, it does cost substantially more in the long run.

Case Studies: Exploring No-Deposit Auto Insurance With Leading Providers

Case Study 1: Online Convenience vs. Long-Term Savings

Sarah, a 28-year-old professional, opted for Progressive’s no-deposit car insurance for its online convenience. Progressive’s promise of an easy online management system appealed to Sarah, who values convenience in her busy lifestyle.

This explores Sarah’s experience over a year, evaluating the simplicity of online interactions and comparing the overall costs with traditional upfront payment options.

Case Study 2: Military Savings and Financial Wisdom

Mark, a military service member, chose USAA for its attractive military savings and reputation for serving the armed forces. Mark, being financially savvy, considered the long-term impact on his budget when opting for USAA’s no-deposit car insurance.

This investigates Mark’s decision, highlighting the financial advantages of no-deposit options and assessing how it aligns with his overall financial goals.

Case Study 3: Customizable Policies and Financial Trade-offs

Olivia, a young professional, chose Liberty Mutual for its customizable policies. Liberty Mutual’s promise of tailoring policies to individual needs appealed to Olivia, who seeks flexibility in her coverage.

This follows Olivia’s journey, examining the trade-offs involved in selecting a no-deposit option. It explores the financial implications of Liberty Mutual’s customizable policies and assesses whether the convenience of no-deposit aligns with Olivia’s budget and coverage preferences.